The 10 BEST Restaurants in Caye Caulker

15 Shares

Reading Time: 5 mins

Caye Caulker is rapidly emerging as a contender to Ambergris Caye as a top destination in Belize, driving a significant expansion in its food scene.

Initially a haven for rugged backpackers, Caye Caulker now attracts a blend of budget and sophisticated travelers, offering the charm and relaxation reminiscent of Ambergris Caye 20 years ago.

The 10 Best Restaurants in Caye Caukler

Below you can find some of the top Caye Caulker restaurants. I’ve curated these spots based on various factors, including consistency, reputation and diversity of food options. I hope you have a wonderful time on La Isla Carinosa!

1. Meldy’s Restaurant

Meldy’s is the top spot to go if you’re looking for an authentic and AFFORDABLE eat-like-a-local experience! A bit hidden near the lagoonside of Caye Caulker, this small restaurant offers a variety of traditional Belizean dishes, including fresh seafood and local specialties like stew meat with coconut rice and beans. I personally love their Belizean favourite fried fish with rice and beans!

2. Reina’s Seafood Grill

Reina’s is known for delicious grilled food and tropical drinks. The Belizean-style restaurant offers many local dishes, including stews, curries and jerk chicken. The main draw is the seafood, and on any given day, you can have a variety of fish, shrimp, and lobster dishes, when in season. It’s very popular among visitors seeking a laidback vibe.

3. Namaste Cafe

A lovely cafe and yoga studio in Caye Caulker, Namaste is known for its healthy North American menu. It offers a variety of vegetarian and vegan dishes, along with fresh juices and smoothies. The cafe’s relaxed atmosphere and recognizable food options makes it a very popular spot for breakfast and lunch.

4. Chef Kareem’s UnBelizeable Lunch

If you’re looking for street food in Caye Caulker, Chef Kareem’s UnBelizeable Lunch is definitely a must try! Located on the beach, right next to the sea, Chef Kareem’s is known for generous portions and vibrant flavors. Any of the seafood dishes are great or try the jerk chicken – it’s seasoned to perfection and absolutely mouthwatering.

5. Ice and Beans Cafe

Ice and Beans is a popular beachside cafe known for its fresh pastries and bagels. With plenty outdoor seating (plus hammocks), a beautiful view of the sea, and a friendly atmosphere, it’s a great place to have breakfast and start your day. Along with the bagels, people rave about the donuts, bubble waffles, and smoothies.

6. Il Pellicano Cucina Italiana

Il Pellicano brings a bit of upscale elegance to the Caye Caulker restaurant scene with its authentic Italian cuisine and charming ambiance. This cozy restaurant offers a range of classic dishes, including homemade pasta, wood-fired pizzas, and delectable seafood options. Enjoy a taste of Italy in the heart of Belize, with dishes crafted from fresh, locally sourced ingredients.

7. Wish Willy Bar & Grill

Operating since 2002, Wish Willy Bar & Grill is a beloved establishment on Caye Caulker. Known for its laid-back atmosphere and delicious grilled seafood, it’s a great no-frills spot to unwind. The open-air setting and live music create a fun, relaxed vibe. Be sure to try their signature grilled lobster or snapper – it’s a crowd favorite.

8. Pasta Per Caso

Pasta Per Caso is another notable Italian restaurant that is popular on the island of Caye Caulker. The owners, who are passionate about Italian cuisine, initially started their business with the intention of producing pasta to sell other restaurants but that quickly changed to a full scale restaurant. I fyou plan to visit, their pasta of the day is a must-try.

9. Maggie’s Sunset Kitchen

Maggie’s Sunset Kitchen is the perfect place to enjoy a meal while watching the sunset. Located on the west side of Caye Caulker, this restaurant offers a mix of Belizean and international dishes. The fresh seafood and beautiful views make it a memorable dining experience. Don’t miss the ceviche – it’s fresh and tangy, the perfect tropical treat.

10. Barefoot Caribe Bar and Grill

Barefoot Caribe Bar and Grill is a beachfront restaurant on the barrier reef side of Caye Caulker that offers a variety of international and Caribbean dishes. Known for its lively atmosphere and scenic views, it is a great place to enjoy a meal or a drink by the water. Service is often slow so come with extra time to enjoy a drink with your toes in the sand.

Bonus: The Lazy Lizard at The Split

The Lazy Lizard is located at The Split, which is the most popular place to hang out in Caye Caulker. Most people visit for famous drinks such as the “Lizard Juice” but once you spend enough time there, you’ll likely end up ordering convenient pub food. You’ll find items such as ceviche, nachos, quesadillas, and burgers on their menu.

Where to Eat in Caye Caulker